Introduction
Football is a game of strategy, skill, and physical prowess. In the NFL, quarterbacks are the most important players on the field. They are the ones who lead their teams to victory by making crucial plays and decisions. Two quarterbacks who have been in the spotlight recently are Derek Carr and Geno Smith. In this article, we will compare and contrast these two quarterbacks to determine who is the better player overall.
Derek Carr’s Career
Derek Carr is a quarterback for the Las Vegas Raiders. He played college football at Fresno State and was drafted by the Raiders in the second round of the 2014 NFL Draft. Carr has been the starting quarterback for the Raiders since his rookie season and has had an impressive career so far.
Throughout his career, Carr has thrown for over 28,000 yards and has 170 touchdowns. He has also been selected to three Pro Bowls and was named Second-team All-Pro in 2016. Carr is known for his accuracy and ability to make quick decisions on the field.
Geno Smith’s Career
Geno Smith is a quarterback for the Seattle Seahawks. He played college football at West Virginia and was drafted by the New York Jets in the second round of the 2013 NFL Draft. Smith has had a tumultuous career in the NFL so far, with a number of ups and downs.
Throughout his career, Smith has thrown for over 6,000 yards and has 29 touchdowns. He has struggled with consistency and has been benched multiple times throughout his career. However, he has also shown flashes of brilliance and has the potential to be a great quarterback.
Statistics Comparison
When comparing the statistics of Derek Carr and Geno Smith, it’s clear that Carr has had the more impressive career so far. As mentioned earlier, Carr has thrown for over 28,000 yards and has 170 touchdowns. Smith, on the other hand, has thrown for just over 6,000 yards and has 29 touchdowns.
In addition, Carr has a higher passer rating and completion percentage than Smith. Carr’s passer rating is 90.7, while Smith’s is just 72.9. Carr’s completion percentage is 64.5%, while Smith’s is just 57.7%. These statistics show that Carr is the more accurate and consistent quarterback of the two.
Leadership Ability
Another important aspect of being a quarterback is leadership ability. A quarterback must be able to lead their team both on and off the field. When it comes to leadership ability, both Carr and Smith have shown that they have what it takes to be successful.
Carr is known for his strong work ethic and dedication to his team. He is often seen working with his teammates during practice and is always looking for ways to improve his game. Smith, on the other hand, has had some issues with his leadership ability in the past. He was involved in a locker room altercation with a teammate during his time with the Jets, which raised questions about his ability to lead a team.
Physical Prowess
When it comes to physical prowess, both Carr and Smith have their strengths and weaknesses. Carr is known for his accuracy and decision-making ability, while Smith is known for his athleticism and ability to make plays with his legs.
However, Carr has had some injury issues throughout his career. In 2016, he suffered a broken leg that ended his season prematurely. Smith, on the other hand, has been relatively healthy throughout his career and has not suffered any major injuries.
Conclusion
After comparing and contrasting the careers of Derek Carr and Geno Smith, it’s clear that Carr is the better quarterback overall. He has had a more impressive career so far and has shown that he has the ability to lead his team both on and off the field. While Smith has shown flashes of brilliance, he has struggled with consistency and has not been able to establish himself as a top-tier quarterback in the NFL.